Book Review: “Royal Renegades: The Children of Charles I and the English Civil Wars” by Linda Porter

Throughout history, many civil wars have altered the course of the history of the countries where they occurred. While we think about the American Civil War, the French Revolution, and the Wars of the Roses, another civil war often overlooked outside of England is the English Civil Wars. A series of conflicts between the Parliamentarians and the Royalists led to the execution of King Charles I and the rise of the English Republic under Oliver Cromwell. We often view the conflict from either Charles’ or Oliver’s perspective, but we have to consider the family that Charles left behind. How did the English Civil Wars mold the children of Charles I and his Catholic Queen Henrietta Maria? Linda Porter explores the lives of the royal children in her book, “Royal Renegades: The Children of Charles I and the English Civil Wars.”

I am a relative novice when it comes to the Stuart dynasty, especially the English Civil Wars. I have seen Linda Porter’s books but have not read any of them yet. I like a challenge so when I saw this book, I decided to give it a try.

Before we explore the lives of the children of Charles I and Henrietta Maria, we must understand how their relationship began in the 1620s. A Protestant English king married a French Catholic princess, the daughter of King Henry IV of France and Marie de Medici. To say that the English did not like having a Catholic queen would be an understatement. Charles I and Maria had nine children in total, but only five would survive into adulthood; Charles II, Princess Mary, James II, Prince Henry, and Henriette Anne. It is through the lives of these five children that we can get a grasp of what kind of impact Charles I’s decisions had on his family as the English Civil Wars took place.

The most difficult part of this book for me was understanding the conflict of the English Civil Wars themselves as it was not an area that I normally study. I think Porter does an admirable job of explaining the causes of the English Civil Wars and how Charles and his family dealt with the anti-royalist resentment. We see the children and Henrietta Maria escape to other countries like France and the Netherlands by any means necessary while Charles I stayed behind. Porter shows her audience that Charles I was a good father until his execution on January 30, 1649. The death of Charles I left a mark on his children. Charles II and James II would have to bid their time and fight for their right to rule after Oliver and Richard Cromwell with a few scandals mixed in. Henriette Anne and Mary would get used to married life with their husbands Philippe Duke of Orleans and William II of Orange respectively.

This is a story of a resilient family who fought for what they believed in, even if it meant that their father died in the process and their country hated them for a time. It is a story of how love and endurance brought the monarchy back from the brink to survive another few centuries. I now want to dive deeper into the Stuart dynasty and read more books by Porter. If you are like me and you want to learn more about the Stuarts and the English Civil Wars, I recommend you read, “Royal Renegades: The Children of Charles I and the English Civil Wars” by Linda Porter.

Guest Post: “A Turbulent Time of Secrets, Spies, and Hidden Treaties” by Elizabeth St. John

I am pleased to welcome Elizabeth St John to my blog to share a guest post about her latest novel, The King’s Intelligencer. I want to thank Elizabeth St John and The Coffee Pot Book Club for allowing me to participate in this blog tour.

The inspiration for The King’s Intelligencer arose from my research for The Godmother’s Secret, centered on the mystery of the missing princes in the Tower of London. During this time, I visited Westminster Abbey, specifically the Chapel of the Innocents, where Sir Christopher Wren’s marble urn—commissioned by Charles II in 1675—allegedly contains the bones of Edward V and Richard, Duke of York. The inscription claims the princes were murdered by their “perfidious uncle Richard the Usurper” and secretly buried in the Tower for 191 years. Standing near the urn, close to where my seventeenth-century character Franny Apsley’s parents, Sir Allen and Frances Apsley, are buried, I began to question the authenticity of this narrative. 

I turned to further research to find out more. Helen Maurer’s paper Bones in the Tower: A Discussion of Time, Place and Circumstance and Annette Carson’s article The Bones in the Urn cast doubt on the identity of the remains. What if these bones weren’t the princes’ at all, but a politically convenient discovery designed to bolster Charles II’s claim to the throne during a period of intense religious and political tension? 

This idea gains significance when we consider the political climate of the late 17th century. Charles II ruled during a time of deep religious divides between Protestants and Catholics. Though Charles outwardly professed Protestantism, he secretly favored Catholicism and converted on his deathbed. His brother, James II, was openly Catholic, which led to his eventual overthrow during the Glorious Revolution of 1688. The discovery of the princes’ bones in 1674 provided Charles II with an opportunity to legitimize his reign, portraying himself as a restorer of justice for the murdered princes, and distancing himself from his brother’s Catholic sympathies. 

The timing of the discovery raised questions about whether the bones were used to manipulate public opinion and strengthen Charles’s position. Further research revealed more secrets. I explored the details of the Secret Treaty of Dover, a clandestine agreement between Charles II and Louis XIV of France. In this treaty, Charles promised to declare himself a Catholic in exchange for financial support. This hidden agreement, uncovered years later, underscores the precarious balance of power in 17th-century England and allowed me to link national concerns to my family history.

 

In this climate of political maneuvering, espionage became crucial. Intelligencers gathered information covertly, often operating unofficially, and reported back to their patrons the news and gossip that was circulating. This secretive world provided the perfect backdrop for my protagonist, Franny Apsley, who navigates the hidden loyalties, treaties, and espionage of 17th-century England. A friend remarked that these intelligencers hung around coffee shops and eavesdropped on other people…which sounded just the kind of thing Franny would have done.  

Franny’s family was deeply involved in real-life espionage. In the third book of The Lydiard Chronicles, Written in Their Stars, we follow her parents, Sir Allen, and Frances Apsley, along with her cousin Nan Wilmot, Countess of Rochester, who were all engaged in covert activities during the English Civil War. Nan cleverly deceived Oliver Cromwell to protect her Royalist family and later negotiated her Parliamentarian relative’s release at the Restoration. Meanwhile, Franny’s brother, Peter Apsley, worked as an intelligencer for Charles II and James II, receiving substantial payments for his covert work. This family history inspired the espionage elements of The King’s Intelligencer, imagining Franny following in their footsteps. 

And what about the bones? Even if the present monarch permits DNA testing, the remains may have deteriorated too much to provide conclusive results. If the bones are proven to belong to the princes, we would still lack crucial details—like the cause of death or the identity of their murderer. The mystery of the bones remains unsolved, leaving historians and novelists alike to speculate. 

The King’s Intelligencer blends historical fact with fiction, following Franny Apsley as she embarks on a dangerous quest for truth. Uncovering hidden secrets and navigating espionage, Franny’s journey ultimately reveals how personal and national histories intersect. This novel is a companion to The Godmother’s Secret and The Lydiard Chronicles, continuing to explore the secrets buried in the past. 

Blurb: 

London, 1674: When children’s bones are unexpectedly unearthed in the Tower of London, England’s most haunting mystery—the fate of the missing princes—is reignited.  

 

Franny Apsley, trusted confidante to Charles II’s beloved niece and heir, Lady Mary Stuart, is caught up in the court’s excitement surrounding the find. Yet, as a dark family secret comes to light, Franny realizes the truth behind the missing princes is far more complex—and dangerous—than anyone suspects. Recruited by her formidable cousin Nan Wilmot,  Dowager Countess of Rochester, to discover the truth behind the bones, Franny is thrust into the shadowy world of intelligencers. But her quest is complicated by an attraction to the charismatic court artist Nicholas Jameson, a recent arrival from Paris who harbors secrets of his own. 

Pursued by Nicholas, Franny searches for evidence hidden in secret family letters and paintings and uncovers a startling diplomatic plot involving Lady Mary, which causes Franny to question her own judgment, threatens the throne, and sets England on a course for war. With only her courage and the guidance of an enigmatic spy within the royal household, Franny must decide how far she will go to expose the truth—and whether that truth will lead to England’s salvation or her own heartbreak. 

In a glittering and debauched society where love is treacherous and loyalty masked, Franny must navigate a world where a woman’s voice is often silenced and confront the ultimate question: What is she willing to risk for the sake of her country, her happiness, and her family’s safety? 

 

A captivating historical novel of conspiracy, passion, and courage, The King’s Intelligencer is one woman’s quest for a truth that could change the fate of a nation. A companion to the critically acclaimed best-selling novels The Godmother’s Secret and The Lydiard Chronicles, The King’s Intelligencer weaves together beloved characters and actual events to bring a suspenseful mystery to life. 

 

 

Buy Links: 

 

This title is available to read on #Kindle Unlimited. 

 

Universal Buy Link: https://geni.us/KingsIntelligencer  

Author Bio

Elizabeth St.John’s critically acclaimed historical fiction novels tell the stories of her ancestors: extraordinary women whose intriguing kinship with England’s kings and queens brings an intimately unique perspective to Medieval, Tudor, and Stuart times. 

Inspired by family archives and residences from Lydiard Park to the Tower of London, Elizabeth spends much of her time exploring ancestral portraits, diaries, and lost gardens. And encountering the occasional ghost. But that’s another story. 

Living between California, England, and the past, Elizabeth is the International Ambassador for The Friends of Lydiard Park, an English charity dedicated to conserving and enhancing this beautiful centuries-old country house and park. As a curator for The Lydiard Archives, she is constantly looking for an undiscovered treasure to inspire her next novel. 

 

Elizabeth’s works include The Lydiard Chronicles, a trilogy set in 17th-century England during the Civil War, and The Godmother’s Secret, which unravels the medieval mystery of the missing princes in the Tower of London. Her latest release, The King’s Intelligencer, follows Franny Apsley’s perilous quest to uncover the truth behind the sudden discovery of the princes’ bones. In Charles II’s court of intrigue and deceit, Franny must decide what she’ll risk—for England’s salvation, her family’s safety, and her own happiness. 

 

 

Author Links

 

Website:

https://www.elizabethjstjohn.com/  

Twitter:

https://x.com/ElizStJohn      

Facebook:

https://www.facebook.com/ElizabethJStJohn/  

LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/in/elizabethjstjohn/  

Instagram:

https://www.instagram.com/elizabethjstjohn/  

Threads:

https://www.threads.net/@elizabethjstjohn  

Bluesky:

https://bsky.app/profile/elizabethstjohn.bsky.social  

Book Bub:

https://www.bookbub.com/profile/elizabeth-st-john  

Amazon Author Page:

https://geni.us/AmazonElizabethStJohn  

Goodreads:

https://geni.us/GoodreadsElizStJohn