Tag: Medieval France

Book Review: “J’Accuse: A Medieval Crime and a Servant Girl Who Changed History” by Jennifer D. Thibodeaux

On By hmalagisiIn Book ReviewsLeave a comment

In 1429, two women’s lives changed for different reasons. For Joan of Arc, it was the year that she led the French to victory and crowned the dauphin King Charles VII of France. In Normandy, it was the year that a young servant girl was violently attacked. The servant girl, Jeanne Corviere, decided to fight against her abuser in court. Her case would forever change the history of Rouen, where the trial was held. What is Jeanne’s story, and what were the results of her trial? Jennifer D. Thibodeaux tells Jeanne’s tale in her book, “J’Accuse: A Medieval Crime and a Servant Girl Who Changed History.”

I would like to thank Godine and Net Galley for sending me a copy of this book. I am always in search of books that provide information about obscure stories from history, so when I saw that this book was about a case of a servant girl and her attackers, it caught my eye. I wanted to see what new information Thibodeaux could provide for this period.

We begin with the day that Jeanne Corviere was attacked by Exupere Le Mire, who had asked Jeanne to help his wife deliver a baby. That was a lie, as Le Mire viciously attacked Jeanne in the woods and left her severely injured. She made her way to the nearest town, and while she was healing, decided that she would sue Exupere Le Mire for compensation. Thibodeaux explains the different types of rape cases while explaining how a woman’s role in society could change how the case was handled. Another aspect that would alter Jeanne’s case was something known as the Privilege of Saint Romain, which allowed the clergy of Rouen to select a prisoner to be released from prison and his or her crimes to be eliminated.

Thibodeaux takes her readers on a journey, telling Jeanne’s story over the course of a decade. We are also introduced to figures behind the scenes that fought either for Jeanne or for Le Mire. She also chooses to pair Jeanne’s story with Joan of Arc’s tragic tale of her trial and execution. While it does provide more context to the overall story of France while Jeanne’s trial was ongoing, it felt a bit distracting to me. I wanted to focus on Jeanne’s story, and it felt as if her story took a back seat for a little bit.

Overall, this was a fine book. I did learn a lot about Jeanne Corviere and her case, and the book was easy to follow. Thibodeaux clearly did her research for such an obscure case. If you want to read a book about a medieval legal case, I recommend you read “J’Accuse: A Medieval Crime and a Servant Girl Who Changed History” by Jennifer D. Thibodeaux.

Book Review: “House of Lilies: The Dynasty That Made Medieval France” by Justine Firnhaber-Baker

On By hmalagisiIn Book ReviewsLeave a comment

The medieval world was a time of great change, epic battles, and warrior kings who kept expanding their kingdoms to levels that we know today. In England, the dynasty that we most associate with the medieval period was the Plantagenets. For medieval France, it was the Capetians, who reigned for centuries after the Carolingians. So how did the Capetians come into power? Who were the major figures and scandals that defined the dynasty? And how did the dynasty come to its end? Justine Firnhaber-Baker explores this topic in her book, “House of Lilies: The Dynasty That Made Medieval France.”

I have seen this book on social media for a while now, and the topic was intriguing to me. I have not read much about medieval France, except in supporting roles when studying medieval English history. I wanted to expand my knowledge about medieval Europe as a whole, so when I saw this book for sale in a bookstore, I knew I wanted to add it to my library.

There has been some debate as to when the Capetian dynasty ended, as the Houses of Valois and Bourbon could be considered smaller branches of the Capetian family. Firnhaber-Baker has marked the time of the Capetians between 987 and 1328, which is a few centuries of drama. The kings of the Capetian dynasty were: Hugh Capet, Robert II the Pious, Henry I, Philip I, Louis VI, Louis VII, Philip II Augustus, Louis VIII the Lion, Saint Louis IX, Philip III the Bold, Philip IV the Fair, Louis X the Stubborn, John I the Posthumous, Philip V the Tall, and Charles IV the Fair. Fifteen Kings of France grew the kingdom into a medieval powerhouse.

Firnhaber-Baker shows how the Capetians turned a fragmented realm that was left behind by the Carolingians into a nation. We get to see Hugh Capet become the first king of a new dynasty and set the groundwork for his predecessors. France slowly became a beacon of Catholicism and the crusading dream, as well as the birthplace of Gothic architecture. We see how one king became a saint and another the mortal enemy of the papacy. And of course, we get to see the Capetians face off against their English neighbors, the Plantagenets.

For a book that covers over 300 years of royal history, I found it extremely well researched and easy to follow. While I did not know a ton about the Capetians before reading this book, I want to learn even more about this dynasty and other medieval dynasties of Europe. If you want to learn more about the Capetian dynasty, I highly recommend you read “House of Lilies: The Dynasty That Made Medieval France” by Justine Firnhaber-Baker.