Book Review: “The Ugly Renaissance: Sex, Greed, Violence and Depravity in an Age of Beauty” by Alexander Lee

The Renaissance has been seen by many as the peak of human creativity and beauty. Masters in every discipline were making a name for themselves. But behind the fair facade, the Renaissance was a human story, and like all human tales, it had its dark, ugly corners. Alexander Lee peels back the pretty picture to show the darker side of the Renaissance in his book, “The Ugly Renaissance: Sex, Greed, Violence and Depravity in an Age of Beauty.”

This was one of my used bookstore finds. I have been on a bit of an Italian Renaissance kick lately, so I am always looking for new information about this era. The title of this book caught my eye, so I decided to give it a try.

We begin with a punched nose. More specifically, the punch that Michelangelo took to the nose when he was a teen, and his assailant was fellow sculptor Pietro Torrigiano. It may seem like an odd place to start, but it sets the tone that Lee is trying to set in this book, which is that great beauty in art can come from dark places. To explain his point, Lee breaks down this book into three major sections: the world of the Renaissance artist, the world of the Renaissance patron, and the Renaissance and the world. In the first section, we focus on the lives of the struggling artists and how they were able to create beauty when their home lives were tumultuous. We then move into the lives of the patrons, the bankers, politicians, popes, and mercenaries who paid for the works of art to be produced. Finally, we get to see how those living in Renaissance Italy interacted with those who were different. Their interactions included those from different faiths, like Jews and Muslims, as well as interactions with slaves from Africa and those living in other corners of the world whose beliefs were very foreign.

Going into this book, I wanted to like it and learn a lot more about the darker side of the Renaissance. Unfortunately, other than learning a few new names and tales from this period, the entire book felt a bit lackluster to me. At some points, especially when he was discussing the bankers, I felt bored with this book. Obviously, I agree with Lee that there is beauty in dark times and that we are due for a Renaissance in the modern age. If you want to read a book about the Renaissance but with a darker tone, you might enjoy “The Ugly Renaissance: Sex, Greed, Violence and Depravity in an Age of Beauty” by Alexander Lee.

Leave a Reply